P.A. Jewelers

More than a Kiss...


P. A. Jewelers is not your average jewelry store. With all the jewelry we buy we have a large supply of always changing fine estate jewelry as well as new and custom designed pieces. From original vintage cameo rings dating back to the 1800’s and vintage diamond rings with original mine and Euro cut diamonds to modern pieces from the top designers as well as our own in-house designed pieces, P. A. Jewelers has the jewelry you are looking for and offers it all at unbeatable prices.


Almost all jewelry stores say they have the best prices.  But if they did, why are they always having sales with 50, 60 and 70% or more off discounts?  Most jewelers will never tell the customer that the jewelry in their cases is marked up 3 to 5 times over their cost, making the jeweler huge profits but taking advantage of the customer in the process.


P. A. Jewelers works differently. Most of our jewelry comes from estates, collections, and individual pieces that customers sell to us. We clean, refurbish, and inspect this jewelry and offer these pieces to our customers as exceptional values.  Want something new?  We have access to the same jewelry, diamond, and gemstone wholesalers as the other jewelry stores, but we choose to mark this jewelry up a fraction of what the other jewelers do again offering our customers exceptional pricing.  We also offer our own custom designed pieces, at the same unbeatable pricing as we prefer to put our customers before profits.  All of this combines to offer our customers the largest and most diverse selection of fine jewelry around.


Come see us before you buy anywhere else, you will be pleasantly surprised at our honest, professional but laid-back staff, large, diverse jewelry selection and very reasonable prices.

Jewelry Customiza­tion

Do you have an inherited piece of jewelry that you just don’t wear or an older piece in your jewelry box that just doesn’t quite fit your current style?  P. A. Jewelers can help you reimagine your own jewelry and enjoys helping our customers design the piece of their dreams.  Many of the pieces in our case can be redesigned to meet your specific desire as well.  Why not reimagine that engagement ring with a blue diamond or a ruby?  We are happy to work with our customers to customize any piece in our cases.  Since much of our jewelry is estate, we often redesign pieces to update them or replace missing or damaged stones; put this experience to work for you.  And with thousands of gemstones and diamonds in stock, the redesign process is easy and offered at a very affordable pricing.

Local Artists

As a small business P. A. Jewelers always likes to support other small businesses.  So instead of ordering in new jewelry lines from a West Coast designer or, even worse, from overseas, we seek out talented local jewelry artists that work in a variety of materials and styles and showcase handmade jewelry from these skilled local jewelry artists.  All of these jewelry artists are from Indiana, and most are from the Hendricks County area.

Fine Watches

Fine timepieces go hand in hand with fine jewelry and P. A. Jewelers offers fine estate wristwatches and pocket watches.  If you are looking for fine American, Swiss, German and other vintage and modern watches, we have a nice selection updated on a regular basis.

If a new watch is what you are looking for P. A. Jewelers is a factory direct authorized Citizen watch dealer.  We stock a large selection of Citizen watches including many of their limited edition and special edition watches as well as their new automatic line.  Because we are an authorized Citizen watch dealer, we can offer our customers an additional year on the factory warranty.  And all our fine timepieces are offered at exceptional pricing.

Gold & Silver Coins

P. A. Jewelers deals in gold and silver coins as well. We stock an ever-changing selection of graded and un-graded coins including American Eagles as well as pre-1965 silver coins like Morgan and Peace dollars. We also stock bulk 90% silver coins, US Mint proof sets, commemoratives, and other collector sets.  We can fill just about any order for 90% silver and American Eagles so if you are looking to expand your silver holdings, P. A. Jewelers is the place to go.


If you invest or collect bullion P. A. Jewelers has what you want.  Our selection of silver rounds and bars is always changing, and we can fill large orders.  If you are more of a collector, we offer various themed and commemorative silver products.  Prefer gold?  P. A. Jewelers can help you with your gold needs as well.

New Jewelry Arrivals

P.A. Jewelers is constantly acquiring new and estate jewelry and we can’t possibly list our entire inventory here. However, we regularly post news of unique or interesting new jewelry items to our website.

  • We originally purchased this piece as a ring, with the shank cut off. When I looked at it, I saw the potential for a pendant. It is now a beautiful 14Kt yellow gold antique pendant with a gorgeous amethyst! I am certain, in its day,......

  • If you are looking for an out-of-the-ordinary engagement ring & wedding band, this could be it! Set in 10Kt white gold, this gorgeous set has a .55Ct heart-shaped diamond at the center! The set is accented by an additional 6 diamonds, 1 on the band......

  • Be race ready with these gorgeous earrings! Set in 18Kt white gold, these checkered flag inspired earrings have 1.0Ct total weight of white diamonds and 1.0Ct total weight of black diamonds! If you are a race fan, these are a must 🏁🏁! #morethanakiss #estatejewelry...

  • Earlier this week, we purchased a large box of miscellaneous gemstones. I spent this afternoon sorting through the box. Thankfully, most of the stones were marked…except for these. Based on their color, I assume them to be beryl or quartz…they will be tested to know......

To receive notifications of the latest jewelry arrivals via email, please fill out the form on the Newsletter Signup page of our website.